My 3 favorite pizzas on Staten Island right now

“Isle Slice” is tossing up the freshest, cheesiest pies in Staten Island. From classic Margherita to inventive Buffalo chicken creations, there’s a slice for everyone.
"Isle Slice" is tossing up the freshest, cheesiest pies in Staten Island. From classic Margherita to inventive Buffalo chicken creations, there’s a slice for everyone.... Read More Below
Picture of Pamela Silvestri

Pamela Silvestri

Aside from my own homemade stuff here’s what I have enjoyed recently. Thoughts? Let me know at Pam@PamelaSilvestri.com.

Number 1:

SEPPE — 3 Navy Pier Ct., Stapleton, 718-727-3773; Seppepizzabar.com — Best is ‘Shroom Thyme which includes intense truffle-ness plus a rich variety of mushrooms like hen of the woods. Categorically on their pan pie situation, the basting-effect created by various cheeses and smart topping combos makes each bite a downright sumptuous experience.

Number 2:

UNGARO —1298 Forest Ave., Port Richmond, 646-968-4777; Ungarocoalfiredpizzacafe.com

Pies are beautiful with carefully arranged toppings and attention to detail such as ricotta cheese piped into dollop flowers. The charcoal touch makes a super crunchy, enormously satisfying crust that can best be appreciated when pies are consumed fresh from the oven.

Number 3:

PIZZERIA GIOVE — 278 New Dorp Ln., New Dorp; 347-286-0635; Pizzeriagiovestatenisland.com

The roasty-ness of each pie and ingredient quality always ups the Giove experience into the gourmet stratosphere. It’s definitely on the pricy side for New York City but a necessary indulgence when touring the borough’s pizza scene.

Staten Eats isn’t just about dining out—it’s about celebrating the unique flavors and traditions that make Staten Island a food lover’s haven. Whether it’s a decades-old pizzeria, a hidden gem serving global cuisine, or a bustling farmers’ market, Pamela’s mission is to connect you to the people and places that make Staten Island’s food scene so special.

Pull up a chair and dig in—whether you’re a local looking for your next favorite spot or a visitor curious about Staten Island’s culinary treasures, Staten Eats is here to inspire your taste buds, one delicious bite at a time.

Share this Article:

Facebook
X
Pinterest

Still hungry? Here’s more:

Appetizing margherita pizza with fresh basil, tomato, and mozzarella on a rustic wooden table